The first step in delegitimizing what the Bible says about homosexuality is to suggest that the Bible hardly says anything about homosexuality. In one sense this is true. The Bible is a big book, and the rightness or wrongness of homosexual practice is not at the center of it. If you read through the 1,189 chapters in the Bible and the more than 30,000 verses, you'll find only a dozen or so passages that deal explicitly with homosexuality.
So does this mean the traditional view of marriage is based on nothing more than a few fragments? Is it fair to say that just six or seven passages have for centuries prevented those engaged in homosexual activity from finding acceptance in the church? Are denominations and families and friendships and organizations and institutions being torn apart because of a small handful of disputed texts concerning a minor issue about which Jesus never even said anything?
Or to ask the question another way: If the Bible says so little about homosexuality, why do Christians insist on talking about it so much?
Let me make six points by way of response.
1. We need to remember that this controversy was not dreamed up by evangelical Christians. The reason there is so much discussion about issues like abortion, euthanasia, and same-sex marriage is because many have sought to legalize and legitimize actions that were, until 50 years ago, considered immoral and illegal. When it comes to the cultural flash points of our day, it hardly seems wise to avoid talking about what everyone else is talking about.
2. The reason the Bible says comparatively little about homosexuality is because it was a comparatively uncontroversial sin among ancient Jews and Christians. There is no evidence that ancient Judaism or early Christianity tolerated any expression of homosexual activity. The Bible says a lot about idolatry, religious hypocrisy, economic injustice, and pagan worship because these were common sins for God's people in both testaments. The Bible talks about bestiality even less than it talks about homosexuality, but that doesn't make bestiality an insignificant issue—or incest or child abuse or 50 other sins the Bible barely addresses. Counting up the number of verses on any particular topic is not the best way to determine the seriousness of the sin involved.
3. Having said all that, it’s not like the Bible is silent on the issue of homosexual behavior. It's explicitly condemned in the Mosaic law (Leviticus) and used as a vivid example of human rebellion in Paul's most important letter (Romans). It's listed among a host of other serious vices in two different epistles (1 Corinthians and 1 Timothy). It's one of the reasons God destroyed the most infamous cities in the Bible (Sodom and Gomorrah). And that's not even mentioning all the texts about marriage in Genesis, in Proverbs, in Song of Solomon, in Malachi, in Matthew, and in Ephesians.
4. Furthermore, there is nothing ambiguous about the biblical witness concerning homosexual behavior. Even many revisionist scholars acknowledge that the Bible is uniformly negative toward same-sex activity. The gay Dutch scholar Pim Pronk, after admitting that many Christians are eager to see homosexuality supported by the Bible, states plainly, "In this case that support is lacking." Although he doesn't think moral positions must be dependent on the Bible (which is why he can support homosexual behavior), as a scholar he recognizes that "wherever homosexual intercourse is mentioned in Scripture, it is condemned."
5. It cannot be overstated how seriously the Bible treats the sin of sexual immorality. Sexual immorality is precisely the sort of sin that characterizes those who will not enter the kingdom of heaven. There are at least eight vice lists in the New Testament (Mark 7:21-22; Romans 1:24-31; 13:13; 1 Corinthians 6:9-10; Galatians 5:19-21; Colossians 3:5-9; 1 Timothy 1:9-10; Revelation 21:8), and sexual immorality is included in every one of these. In fact, in seven of the eight lists there are multiple references to sexual immorality (e.g., impurity, sensuality, orgies, men who practice homosexuality), and in most of the passages some kind of sexual immorality heads the lists. You would be hard-pressed to find a sin more frequently, more uniformly, and more seriously condemned in the New Testament than sexual sin.
6. To insist that Jesus never said anything about homosexuality is not really accurate. Not only did He explicitly reaffirm the creation account of marriage as the one-flesh union of a man and a woman (Matthew 19:4-6; Mark 10:6-9); He condemned the sin of porneia (Mark 7:21), a broad word encompassing every kind of sexual sin. The leading New Testament lexicon defines porneia as "unlawful sexual intercourse, prostitution, unchastity, fornication." Likewise, New Testament scholar James Edwards states that porneia "can be found in Greek literature with reference to a variety of illicit sexual practices, including adultery, fornication, prostitution, and homosexuality. In the Old Testament it occurs for any sexual practice outside marriage between a man and a woman that is prohibited by the Torah."
Jesus didn't have to give a special sermon on homosexuality because all of His listeners understood that same-sex behavior was prohibited in the Pentateuch and reckoned as one of the many expressions of sexual sin (porneia) off limits for the Jews. Besides all this, there's no reason to treat Jesus' words (all of which were recorded by someone other than Jesus) as more authoritative than the rest of the Bible. He affirmed the abiding authority of the Old Testament (Matt. 5:17-18) and understood that His disciples would fill out the true meaning of His person and work (John 14:25-26; 16:12-15; cf. Luke 24:48-49; Acts 1:1-2).
We cannot count same-sex behavior as an indifferent matter. Of course, homosexuality isn't the only sin in the world, nor is it the most critical one to address in many church contexts. But if 1 Corinthians 6 is right, it's not an overstatement to say that solemnizing same-sex sexual behavior—like supporting any form of sexual immorality—runs the risk of leading people to hell.
Scripture often warns us—and in the severest terms—against finding our sexual identity apart from Christ and against pursuing sexual practice inconsistent with being in Christ (whether that's homosexual sin, or, much more frequently, heterosexual sin). When we tolerate the doctrine which affirms homosexual behavior, we are tolerating a doctrine which leads people further from God. This is not the mission Jesus gave His disciples when He told them to teach the nations everything He commanded.
The biblical teaching is consistent and unambiguous: Homosexual activity is not God's will for His people. Silence in the face of such clarity is not prudence, and hesitation in light of such frequency is not patience. The Bible says more than enough about homosexual practice for us to say something, too.
Adapted excerpt from What Does the Bible Really Teach About Homosexuality? Copyright © 2015 Kevin DeYoung. Published by Crossway. All rights reserved. Used with permission.
1. As the cultural view of sexuality becomes increasingly pervasive, it’s important for us to revisit what the Bible has to say on the subject. Read “Why Did God Invent Sex?” and “Is It True That Jesus Never Addressed Same-Sex Marriage?”
2. Listen as Kevin DeYoung tells FamilyLife Today® radio listeners what the Bible says about homosexuality.
3. Read What Does the Bible Really Teach About Homosexuality?